MARA E. KARLINASSOCIATE
The National Defense Strategy’s plough toward Russian Federation in addition to Red People's Republic of China requires the U.S. armed services to alter its Gulf assets. A meaningful review of U.S. forcefulness posture inwards the Middle East is long overdue.
We explored why inwards the starting fourth dimension article inwards our serial for Defense One, noting challenges amongst Iran, contest amongst Russian Federation in addition to China, counterterrorism imperatives, in addition to domestic political in addition to budgetary realities. This assessment has alone been reinforced yesteryear the subsequent release of the Trump Administration’s National Defense Strategy, or NDS, amongst its focus on strategic contest amongst Red People's Republic of China in addition to Russia, equally good equally the administration’s hard-line approach to Iran.
In our minute article, nosotros examined a attain of Middle East scenarios in addition to identified 4 factors to consider when reshaping regional forcefulness posture. Now, nosotros offering around recommendations most gradually changing that posture to reverberate evolving priorities in addition to challenges.
To live clear, the U.S. armed services volition never larn out the Middle East. We are non advocating that it do so. However, if Defense Secretary Mattis wants to fulfill the NDS mandate to focus on Red People's Republic of China in addition to Russia, the U.S. military’s posture inwards the Middle East must larn smaller in addition to smarter.
First, the States must increase the emphasis of non-military tools, which volition live vital to enabling regional partners to address long-term challenges of governance, fraying of social contracts, in addition to consolidating counter terrorism in addition to territorial gains into stabilization. Such initaitives volition require sustained in addition to accountable funding from both the Department of State in addition to USAID, whose budgets convey been slashed inwards the starting fourth dimension 2 years of the Trump Administration. In addition, the States has nonetheless to appoint equally many equally one-half of its Ambassadors to the region. While career foreign, civil, in addition to armed services service officers tin send forrad initiatives quite capably, the absence of the President’s representatives inwards fundamental partner countries limits the political effectiveness of the States at a fourth dimension when geopolitical competitors such equally Russian Federation in addition to Red People's Republic of China are deepening their relationships inwards the part – in addition to mightiness to broker the posture adjustments nosotros recommend inwards this article. To this point, the direction must hold off beyond ane ordinarily used tool — U.S.arms sales — to compete amongst growing Russian influence inwards the Middle East; it must strengthen other U.S. diplomatic, economic, tidings in addition to strategic communication tools that volition live critical to enabling a competitive strategy inwards the region.
Second, the States should gradually reshape its “furniture” inwards the part — that is, its armed services bases, assets, in addition to armed services personnel inwards the Middle East. This may involve reductions but amongst an emphasis on smart investments. The finish should live to larn out plenty for ongoing operations in addition to probable potential contingencies, nonetheless assume around adventure inwards less probable scenarios equally prescribed yesteryear the NDS, which calls for “calculated risk-taking” 5 times inwards its unclassified summary. For example, CENTCOM could relax its requirements for a continuously acquaint carrier blast group. Ground forces in addition to blast assets could also live drawn downward somewhat. Finally, the proliferation in addition to growth of service in addition to unified ascendancy headquarters inwards the Gulf part should live rolled dorsum through delayering in addition to reducing staff numbers. This terminal number volition also strengthen U.S. civilian actors inwards the part yesteryear minimizing the viceroy dynamic that has gained steam over the terminal 2 decades.
What U.S. forces should stay to deter Iran, counter terrorism, secure access to strategic waterways, in addition to back upwards allies in addition to partners? Important elements include:
Ballistic missile defense.
Adaptable naval in addition to marine configurations that furnish littoral, amphibious, lift, strike, maritime domain awareness, in addition to maritime safety capabilities.
Special operations in addition to counter terrorism capabilities.
Intelligence, surveillance, in addition to reconnaissance capabilities.
Logistics in addition to enablers required to perform these functions.
Third, the States should streamline its armed services bases inwards the region. Research yesteryear the RAND Corporation has upended a center assumption of the role of bases inwards securing access for contingencies; a 2014 study establish that “the presence of large permanent bases does non increase the likelihood of securing contingency access.” The array of U.S. bases, primarily situated inwards the Gulf, that convey been sustained in addition to built upon since the 1991 Gulf War, were critical to conducting successive wars inwards Republic of Iraq in addition to stay thus for operations inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan in addition to efforts to care terrorism in addition to deter Iran. While the latter 3 missions volition stay fundamental features of the U.S. regional approach across a attain of possible scenarios, conducting these operations in addition to preparing for the possible crises in addition to contingencies that may emanate from hereafter conflicts do non ask keeping all of its electrical current bases “hot” inwards the region. “Hot” bases are continuously manned, operated, in addition to maintained yesteryear the primary forcefulness user – inwards this instance the States – in addition to the host nation. Instead, the States could shift around of its bases from “hot” to “warm,” primarily operated in addition to maintained yesteryear the host province nether an understanding that permits U.S. forces to surge at that topographic point when needed.
The criteria for determining which bases should live hot in addition to warm could live based upon the type of capabilities needed inwards certainly parts of the region, where strong security-cooperation relationships already be to burden-share capabilities, in addition to calculations of where the States could assume around risk. One instance to consider is Kuwait, where the U.S. military’s long in addition to deep human relationship could let for a transition to warm bases in addition to where a heavy ground-based posture is less relevant for the region’s challenges. Such transitions could live offset yesteryear farther safety cooperation investsments to assure critical Gulf partners of U.S. commitment.
Fourth, the States volition demand to blueprint a serial of mitigation measures to absorb whatever risks of adjusting its electrical current forcefulness posture. These steps should include increasing prepositioned equipment stocks inwards the part in addition to deepening safety partnerships through tailored in addition to targeted advising, establishment building, training, exercises, exchanges, in addition to equipping to enable partners to address mutual safety objectives. Exercises amongst a number of regional militaries, for example, are useful both strategically— deterring Iran, reassuring Gulf partners, in addition to facilitating cooperation amid them given frayed political relationships—and operationally inwards ensuring the U.S. armed services maintains readiness for hereafter Middle East conflicts, especially equally it focuses increasingly on other regions. Working amongst allies such equally the U.K. in addition to French Republic to puddle resources, basing, in addition to synchronizing carrier deployments equally allied capabilities in addition to regional bases come upwards on business would also assist offset changes inwards U.S. posture. Harnessing opporutnities to part resources across U.S. combatant commands also provides efficiencies; CENTCOMalready shares ISR resources amongst AFRICOM. Future sharing amongst EUCOM, AFRICOM, in addition to INDOPACOM could include maritime in addition to blast capabilities. And spell nosotros convey focused on posture adjustments, undoubtedly at that topographic point are changes that could live made inwards forcefulness development, too, such equally investments inwards safety forcefulness assistance brigades in addition to lite assail aircraft.
We do non recommend these adjustments lightly, equally threats in addition to challenges persist inwards the Middle East region. The administration’s determination to take away the States from the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action to curb Iran’s nuclear programme in addition to attempt a to a greater extent than assertive approach to address Iran’s destabilizing behaviour may trigger escalations that the States volition demand to live prepared to address—in unopen coordination amongst allies in addition to partners. However, changing realities of the safety environs in addition to U.S. political in addition to budgetary dynamics convey prompted deep introspection inwards the Defense Department. It’s fourth dimension to brand gradual adjustments inwards the CENTCOM home to reverberate it.
Congress should chore the Pentagon to consider how to reshape its posture, reporting dorsum through both classified in addition to unclassified, publicly available assessments. These assessments should include an explanation of how DoD plans to apply its global operating model in addition to dynamic forcefulness occupation concepts outlined inwards the NDS inwards the Middle East context in addition to how state of war plans volition necessarily also alter amongst posture adjustments. The part volition choke along to pose considerable in addition to evolving challenges to U.S.national security. U.S. policymakers should aim to shape U.S.posture to live flexible, adaptive, in addition to responsive to view requirements inwards the CENTCOM home but also inwards the context of global priorities.
Buat lebih berguna, kongsi:
