Nilanthan Niruthan
For the get-go fourth dimension inwards human history, nosotros alive inwards an historic flow where in that location are no agency to predict the applied scientific discipline dictating life a mere few years from now. Innovations inwards several fields similar medicine, communication as well as data occur at such a rapid stride that the lifestyle of an average human beingness today is probable to live unrecognizable from that of someone a decade downwardly the line. The most concerning implication of this phenomenon is inwards warfare, where policymakers today are already having to expression themselves alongside emerging technologies that volition milk shiver the really roots of how nosotros wage war. The number of biological enhancement is i of the biggest concerns. Many major powers inwards the international arena are speedily developing agency to give their soldiers capabilities that locomote yesteryear human boundaries.
“Soldiers having no physical, physiological, or cognitive limitation volition live key to survival as well as operational ascendence inwards the future.” (Jacobsen, 2018). These were non the words of a futurologist or academic, but Michael Goldblatt, the quondam Director of the Defense Sciences Office, created yesteryear the U.S Department of Defense for armed services inquiry as well as evolution purposes. Imagine soldiers who tin sack saltation over buildings, communicate telepathically, regenerate wounds straight off as well as require no sleep. While this would remove keep fit within the comforting realm of scientific discipline fiction before the 21st century, such capabilities are good on their way to reality. Militaries around the Earth today are working on applied scientific discipline that enhances the biological capacity of the human soldier (Hanlon, 2018). This study volition supply a hold back into some of the major enhancement methods currently pursued yesteryear States. It volition as well as then consider how such changes mightiness fundamentally impact warfare. It volition non bargain alongside the moral as well as ethical dilemmas raised yesteryear such approaches, every bit those questions remove keep already been covered inwards to a greater extent than comprehensive studies (Lin, 2018).
Technological Overview
The get-go part of this analysis provides an overview of the predominant technological trends that volition manifest themselves on the battlefields of the future.
Exoskeletons
In May 2016, it was reported that Hyundai had created an exoskeleton, a ‘suit’ that allowed the wearer to send 110 pounds as well as send the charge over long distances without difficulty. It could live revolutionary inwards its powerfulness to empower the lives of the elderly as well as victims of spinal cord injury. The companionship fifty-fifty went every bit far to compare the novel suit alongside the iconic “Iron Man” suit (Muoio, 2018), which does assist i envision where hereafter developments are headed. As a thing of fact, the Raytheon Sarcos XOS, an advanced exoskeleton the Pentagon is currently working on, is said to live thus similar to Iron Man that when it was shown to Adi Granov, i of the original illustrators of the comic, he allegedly said “I knew that's where nosotros were heading, but I didn't realize nosotros were this close…that’s Iron Man.” (Mone, 2018). The second-generation version of the suit, XOS 2, already allows the user to elevator over 200 pounds several hundred times alongside no fatigue as well as punch through 3 inches of solid woods (McMillan, 2018). The United States of America Special Operations Command is working on a lighter suit called TALOS – which would live used for tactical assaults yesteryear infantry forces (Hollings, 2018). The USA is non solitary inwards this; armies around the Earth are already developing their ain programs to utilisation exoskeletons for armed services applications.
Russia for example, has announced plans to locomote on an exoskeleton made of titanium (Sharkov, 2018). The Moscow based, State-owned Central Research Institute for Precision Machine Building latterly unveiled combat suits called Ratnik-3, to live operational inwards the side yesteryear side few years. It drew comparisons to fiction i time again, alongside observers noting that they lent a “stormtrooper” effect inwards appearance (Caughill, 2018). Like its American equivalent, it is said to live capable of lending a bang-up bargain of strength, speed as well as stamina to whoever wears the suit. NATO has woken upward too, launching its “Integration of the Exoskeleton inwards the Battlefield Project”, a serial of workshops designed to explore armed services applications every bit good (Marinov, 2018).
East Asia is non far behind. In early on 2018, it was reported that PRC as well as Nippon were already engaged inwards a commercial race to atomic number 82 the global exoskeleton market, predicted to attain nearly USD seven billion over the side yesteryear side decade (Prakash, 2018). Nippon has been especially active inwards developing armed services interest, revealing a couplet of robotic legs that could potentially assist soldiers saltation bang-up distances alongside ease, every bit far dorsum every bit their 2012 Defense symposium (Simpson, 2018). Earlier this year, the Chinese government’s manufacturer of armored vehicles, Norinco, revealed the 2nd generation of its armed services exoskeleton (Lin as well as Singer, 2018), capable of feats comparable to the American as well as Russian versions.
Genetic Manipulation
Another method currently beingness pursued to create super-soldiers, is cistron manipulation. PRC has latterly made huge breakthroughs inwards this area, successfully correcting genetic mutations inwards human embryos, giving nascency to the possibility of much greater gene-editing than before. While such techniques volition i time over again live vital inwards the medical sector, worries soundless abound that PRC mightiness utilisation this cognition to create genetically enhanced soldiers, alongside physical as well as mental capabilities that were hardwired into them every bit embryos. These fears are non unfounded. H5N1 few months earlier, Chinese scientists had revealed that hyper muscular test-tube dogs were successfully bred inwards laboratories (Regalado, 2018). These dogs would remove keep twice the musculus majority of a normal one, alongside a considerable speed as well as strength advantage. Once the same tin sack live done alongside human genes, weaponized soldiers could live created too.
China’s most formidable global rival, the USA, has already identified genome editing every bit a potential threat, especially from countries exterior the Western Earth that exercise non necessarily operate within regulatory or fifty-fifty ethical boundaries (Eastwood, 2018). However, it is of import to annotation that the Pentagon has itself invested quite heavily into cistron modification inquiry (Neslen, 2018), although non for the enhancement of soldiers. Russian Federation has also been quite song inwards raising concerns over genetically enhanced soldiers. While speaking at a youth festival inwards Sochi, Russian President Vladimir Putin himself stated that playing alongside the genetic code would atomic number 82 to disaster, adding ominously that such super-soldiers of the hereafter could live to a greater extent than destructive than a nuclear weapon (Jasurek, 2018).
With the stride at which inquiry inwards genetics is proceeding, it is good within the realm of possibility that States volition live able to alter the deoxyribonucleic acid construction of an embryo, creating a novel breed of humans whose biological characteristics are geared towards gaining supremacy inwards the battlefield. It could live anything from muscular endurance to enhanced senses – in that location is no quantifiable boundary to where such endeavors mightiness remove keep us if these methods are mastered.
Performance Enhancing Drugs
The utilisation of drugs to empower soldiers to part beyond their normal boundary is naught new. Icelandic folk tales advise that the infamously ferocious Viking “berserkers” could remove keep been nether the influence of agaric mushrooms as well as bog myrtle (Holloway, 2018). The utilisation of stimulants similar amphetamine is at nowadays beingness used yesteryear non-State actors similar ISIS every bit well, who exploit the feel of euphoria as well as fearlessness it gives (Sisk, 2018).
In 1937, Pervitin was patented inwards Nazi Germany, a methamphetamine-based drug that enhances physical performance as well as helps resist fatigue. It is said to remove keep played a crucial role inwards High German victory inwards the invasion of France, every bit drugged soldiers marched through perilously exhausting terrain for ii days without slumber as well as broke through French defenses (Cooke, 2018).The drug became thus much of a threat that factories producing it had to live bombed yesteryear the Allies (McCarthy, 2018). Essentially, those Nazi invaders were early on prototypes of super-soldiers.
The utilisation of performance enhancing drugs inwards state of war took an fifty-fifty steeper plunge inwards the Vietnam War, when many U.S soldiers were nether the heavy influence of stimulants similar amphetamine, which helped them remain alert. So rampant was the utilisation of drugs that it has fifty-fifty been called the get-go “pharmacological war” (Rickett, 2018). There are a number of supplements as well as drugs on the marketplace seat today meant to assist i pay attending longer, think faster, retrieve to a greater extent than etc. As they grow inwards potency, the cognitive benefits they give would live far beyond what nosotros perceive now.
The potential for using drugs to create super-soldiers goes good beyond that. Drugs could assist soldiers suspension natural limits effortlessly. According to Ben Chitty, senior projection managing director for biomedical, human performance as well as canine portfolios inwards the Science as well as Technology business office of the United States of America Special Operations Command, some of the abilities that are beingness explored at the instant are those humans are non biologically adapted to, such every bit breathing inwards high height as well as fifty-fifty underwater (Larter, 2018).
While armed services experts exterior the USA remove keep been skeptical of how successful such drugs could be, it is quite possible that the other global powers are currently pursuing options along these lines every bit well, albeit unreported. Considering the number of nature’s laws that remove keep already been subverted yesteryear pharmaceutical drugs (the eradication of diverse diseases for example), it is non far-fetched to assume that they would locomote a long way inwards helping us bypass physical as well as cognitive limits.
Surgical Implants
In 2011, Russian media giant Pravda made controversial statements well-nigh super-soldier experiments conducted on Russian volunteers every bit far dorsum every bit World War II. It claimed that from 1936 to 1941, Soviet scientists implanted golden electrodes into the brains of hundreds of volunteers, thereby controlling the nervus centers to brand them immune to pain. It also stated that physical enhancements were tried during this period, alongside their limbs receiving titanium implants that allegedly protected soft tissue against landmines, shells as well as gunshot injuries (Ackerman, 2018). It alleged that these experiments were eventually deemed a failure, every bit the implants created tumors as well as the bones rejected the metal. While these claims remove keep been rubbished yesteryear numerous commentators, in that location is legitimate inquiry underway today along similar lines.
The U.S armed services has already invested over 65 i G k USD inwards developing a software that tin sack live uploaded to the human encephalon that volition non entirely heighten the senses of the soldier, but could brand them highly resistant to blindness as well as paralysis (Martin, 2018). The enhancement of senses would extend beyond normal limits, including black vision as well as the powerfulness to discovery magnetic fields (Holmes, 2018). Implants remove keep been touted every bit possessing bang-up potential inwards the plain of medicine, alongside armies already trying to decipher how they tin sack live used to struggle mental as well as physical illnesses inwards the battlefield. However, it does non destination there.
Feats that would live considered telepathy as well as mind-control inwards a dissimilar era, are unopen to beingness possible today thank yous to microchip technology. In 2013, Duke University inwards North Carolina reported that they had successfully managed to brand lab rats communicate telepathically, using implants inserted into their primary motor cortex (Heaven, 2018). Russian Federation may non live far behind the USA either, every bit senior American officers are already accusing Russian scientists of working on enhancement implants to create super soldiers. On the battlefield, abilities similar telepathic interaction would hateful combatants could liaise alongside each other fifty-fifty quicker as well as over longer distances. H5N1 warning telephone telephone would no longer involve a dramatic holler as well as response – it could live a neural message sent right into an ally’s encephalon to duck. Undercover operatives inwards a crowded marketplace could ‘talk’ to each other piece apart, pretending to live busy shopping.
Impact on Warfare
This department of the study shall at nowadays focus on the diverse ways inwards which warfare mightiness live transformed, i time these technologies start enabling States to operationalize super-soldiers. The predominant way of conflict nosotros meet today is oftentimes characterized every bit “unconventional” warfare. Typically, these fights involve both State as well as Non-State Actors, in that location is no fixed physical infinite that is designated every bit the battlefield, civilians are oftentimes targeted inwards attacks, as well as distinguishing betwixt combatants as well as non-combatants is almost impossible.
Flipping the Asymmetry?
The most obvious interrogation that straight off comes to remove heed is whether this volition ‘flip’ or counter the advantages non-State actors savour inwards an asymmetric matchup, where smaller insurgent groups tin sack oftentimes defeat wealthier States. Most comprehensive studies on the history of irregular warfare seem to seat a handful of mutual factors guerillas utilisation to their payoff against larger armies – mobility, stealth as well as terrain familiarity (Boot, 2013). In a match-up betwixt an insurgent strength as well as a State army, the quondam depends on the excellence of individuals as well as pocket-size groups rather than larger formations. With the ascent of super-soldiers however, it remains to live seen if this imbalance volition locomote on to exist, given how States are far likelier to develop such applied scientific discipline before non-State actors do.
As familiar every bit an insurgent grouping mightiness live alongside the terrain, every bit stealthily every bit they mightiness live able to displace about, every bit swiftly every bit they may live able to strike, would groups similar the Vietcong or Mujahedeen actually remove keep been every bit effective against the USA or USSR respectively, if the global powers at the fourth dimension had private soldiers capable of superhuman feats? It is oftentimes the lack of maneuverability that is the undoing of larger forces against insurgents. If States tin sack wield the same form of hard powerfulness through a pocket-size contingent of enhanced soldiers every bit having a large armed services footprint, insurgent groups volition discovery themselves facing a completely novel adversary, who plays the same game they exercise but alongside vastly superior skills. It is fifty-fifty possible that unconventional warfare no longer remains the preferred fighting style of insurgents.
The province of affairs of course, could live reversed inwards the instance of proxy warfare. It is non hard to envision a scenario where a State that does possess such cognition imparts it to a non-State thespian operating inwards some other State’s territory. This could atomic number 82 to a terrifying province of affairs where the insurgents, unbound yesteryear legal or moral obligations, at nowadays remove keep the type of abilities that brand guerilla warfare fifty-fifty to a greater extent than effective against a larger Earth forces without such enhancements. This is especially concerning given the frequency alongside proxy warfare happens around the Earth today, since the world’s nuclear powers are no longer inwards a seat where they tin sack afford a directly confrontation alongside each other.
If it is possible for States to create super soldiers, the same applied scientific discipline lent to an insurgent or terrorist grouping could good atomic number 82 to some other nightmare on the battlefield – the super-terrorist, capable of all the devastation alongside none of the responsibility. Particularly worrying is the tendency of ‘Fidayeen’ attacks, a model of assault inwards which a pocket-size cluster of well-trained commandos engage inwards violent combat alongside a selected target, wreaking every bit much havoc every bit possible. It is non a suicide onrush per se, every bit the goal of the attacker is non to snuff it but to inflict every bit many casualties every bit possible before succumbing to injuries or escaping (Sullivan as well as Elkus, 2015). While far to a greater extent than hard to execute than a bomb nail or rural ambush, it attracts unprecedented media attending as well as strikes a to a greater extent than critical blow against the psyche of the land as well as its population. Fidayeen attacks are becoming the favorite tactics of insurgent groups.
Though such assaults remove keep been mutual for to a greater extent than than a decade, it was non until the 26/11 slaughter inwards Bombay that it came to the fore. Jihadist groups all over the Earth remove keep emulated it since then, most notably inwards events similar the Westgate Mall onrush inwards Nairobi as well as the Charlie Hebdo massacre inwards Paris. They oftentimes remove keep tragic consequences, similar inwards Dec 2014 when 132 children were slaughtered yesteryear the Pakistani Taliban is i of the most gruesome Fidayeen attacks ever. If crudely trained terrorists alongside a depression budget are capable of such destruction, the potential for what super-terrorists tin sack inflict on an unsuspecting urban heart as well as soul is peradventure amend left unsaid.
Making Intervention Easier
The advent of super-soldiers could also teach inwards much easier for U.S. who possess them to resort to war. The loss of life as well as limb to soldiers inwards combat is oftentimes the backbone of anti-war sentiment, especially inwards protracted conflicts, as well as is a restraining component for whatsoever government’s armed services ambitions. The anti-war displace strongly affected the world mood against American intervention inwards both Republic of Iraq as well as Afghanistan, non to cite the Vietnam War decades earlier. In Sri Lanka, the enormous losses incurred yesteryear the Earth forces against the LTTE demoralized the province thus greatly inwards the 1990s that Presidential candidates rose as well as savage based on their powerfulness to convince the population they would live the ones to deliver peace. Even inwards undemocratic societies, where world pull per unit of measurement area may non live every bit potent, casualties exercise inhibit the State’s powerfulness to construct nationalistic fervor as well as rally the people to back upward a armed services venture.
Consider American drone strikes inwards Pakistan. Since the computer program started inwards 2007, it has been reported that over 600 civilian lives as well as over 2500 combatants remove keep been killed (Serle, 2016). However, in that location is footling to no exam of this inwards mainstream American media. There are no nationwide protests as well as daily debates on the cost paid yesteryear the land for such a war. This is largely due to i argue – no American soldier has been sent dwelling occupation solid inwards a casket because of the drone offensive inwards Pakistan. It is clear that the utilisation of strength inwards a unusual Earth tin sack neglect to locomote a “talking point” dorsum home, when in that location are no soldiers returning dead. As casualties driblet alongside the nascency of combatants who are nearly impossible to kill, richer States that teach their hands on enhancement applied scientific discipline could discovery themselves able to wage state of war far to a greater extent than rampantly than before, without having to worry well-nigh world pressure.
Conclusion
Technology is never deterministic; it never actually tells us what to exercise alongside it. It is the responsibleness of policymakers to create upward one's remove heed how regional as well as international powers answer to this. While it mightiness audio frightening, it is worthwhile to retrieve that these advancements volition also atomic number 82 to unbelievable progress inwards medicine, alongside the same empowerment methods used to assist those alongside genetic disabilities, paralysis, dementia as well as a host of other debilitating conditions. On the battlefield, the existent impact volition ultimately come upward downwardly to which path humanity chooses to pursue. The i constant inwards the history of warfare is the arrival of novel types of fighters – the disciplined legionnaire, the guerilla on horseback, the heavily armored knight, the suicide assassin; they were the equivalents of super-soldiers inwards their era. While it must live said that biological enhancements tin sack alter warfare on a far greater scale, i tin sack soundless depict some comfort from the fact that humanity is soundless here, e'er adapting as well as surviving. For now.
References
Jacobsen, A. (2015). How the Pentagon Is Engineering Humans for War. [online] The Atlantic. Available at: https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2015/09/military-technology-pentagon-robots/406786/ [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Hanlon, M. (2011). 'Super soldiers': The call for for the ultimate human killing machine. [online] The Independent. Available at: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/super-soldiers-the-quest-for-the-ultimate-human-killing-machine-6263279.html [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Lin, P. (2012). More Than Human? The Ethics of Biologically Enhancing Soldiers. [online] The Atlantic. Available at: https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/02/more-than-human-the-ethics-of-biologically-enhancing-soldiers/253217/ [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Muoio, D. (2016). Hyundai created its ain 'Iron Man' exoskeleton suit. [online] Business Insider. Available at: http://www.businessinsider.com/hyundai-creates-iron-man-exoskeleton-photos-2016-5 [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Mone, G. (2008). Building the Real Iron Man. [online] Popsci.com. Available at: https://www.popsci.com/scitech/article/2008-04/building-real-iron-man [Accessed 31 May 2018].
McMillan, G. (2010). Raytheon’s XOS2: I Am Iron Man… Or The Closest Thing Real Life Has To Offer. [online] TIME.com. Available at: http://techland.time.com/2010/09/27/raytheons-xos2-i-am-iron-man-or-the-closest-thing-real-life-has-to-offer/ [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Hollings, A. (2018). SOCOM's TALOS 'Iron Man' suit volition live delayed some other year. [online] SOFREP. Available at: https://sofrep.com/102999/socoms-talos-iron-man-suit-will-be-delayed-another-year/ [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Sharkov, D. (2017). Russian Federation has developed a titanium exoskeleton for its hereafter soldiers. [online] Newsweek. Available at: http://www.newsweek.com/russia-has-made-titanium-exoskeleton-future-wars-it-has-one-problem-749569 [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Caughill, P. (2017). Russia's next-gen combat suit is getting tech that's resistant to nuclear blasts. [online] Futurism. Available at: https://futurism.com/russias-next-gen-combat-suit-is-getting-tech-thats-resistant-to-nuclear-blasts/ [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Marinov, B. (2018). NATO Integration of the Exoskeleton inwards the Battlefield Project. [online] Available at: https://exoskeletonreport.com/2018/01/nato-integration-of-the-exoskeleton-in-the-battlefield-project/ [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Prakash, A. (2018). PRC as well as Nippon Lead Asian Exoskeleton Development. [online] Robotics Business Review. Available at: https://www.roboticsbusinessreview.com/robo-dev/china-and-japan-lead-asian-exoskeleton-development/ [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Simpson, J. (2015). The Japanese Military Is Building a Robotic Exoskeleton. [ONLINE] Available at: https://warisboring.com/the-japanese-military-is-building-a-robotic-exoskeleton/. [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Lin, J. as well as Singer, P. (2018). China's working on the side yesteryear side generation of armed services exoskeleton. [online] Available at: https://www.popsci.com/china-exoskeleton-next-generation [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Regalado, A. (2015). First Gene-Edited Dogs Reported inwards PRC - MIT Technology Review. [ONLINE] Available at: https://www.technologyreview.com/s/542616/first-gene-edited-dogs-reported-in-china/. [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Eastwood, B. (2017). Gene-Editing inwards China: Beneficial Science or Emerging Military Threat?. [online] Atlantic Council. Available at: http://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/futuresource/gene-editing-in-china-beneficial-science-or-emerging-military-threat [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Neslen, A. (2017). United States of America armed services agency invests $100m inwards genetic extinction technologies. [online] The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/dec/04/us-military-agency-invests-100m-in-genetic-extinction-technologies [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Jasurek, C. (2017). Vladimir Putin Warns of Genetically Engineered Super Soldiers ‘Worse Than a Nuclear Bomb’. [online] www.theepochtimes.com. Available at: https://www.theepochtimes.com/vladimir-putin-warns-of-genetically-engineered-super-soldiers-worse-than-a-nuclear-bomb_2339195.html [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Holloway, A. (2014). The Viking Berserkers – violent warriors or drug-fuelled madmen?. [online] Ancient Origins. Available at: http://www.ancient-origins.net/myths-legends/viking-berserkers-fierce-warriors-or-drug-fuelled-madmen-001472 [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Sisk, R. (2017). ISIS Fighters inwards Raqqa Hopped Up on Amphetamines: United States of America Military. [online] Available at: https://www.military.com/daily-news/2017/08/16/isis-fighters-raqqa-hopped-up-amphetamines-us-military.html [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Cooke, R. (2016). High Hitler: how Nazi drug abuse steered the class of history. [online] The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2016/sep/25/blitzed-norman-ohler-adolf-hitler-nazi-drug-abuse-interview [Accessed 31 May 2018].
McCarthy, B. (2016). H5N1 brief history of state of war as well as drugs: From Vikings to Nazis. [online] Aljazeera.com. Available at: https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/2016/10/history-war-drugs-vikings-nazis-161005101505317.html [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Rickett, O. (2016). How Drugs Have Been Used inwards Basically Every War Ever to Make Soldiers Better at Killing. [online] Vice. Available at: https://www.vice.com/sv/article/kwxdby/drugs-have-been-used-in-pretty-much-every-war-ever-shooting-up [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Larter, D. (2017). 'Performance enhancing drugs' considered for Special Operations soldiers. [online] Defense News. Available at: https://www.defensenews.com/digital-show-dailies/sofic/2017/05/16/performance-enhancing-drugs-considered-for-special-operations-soldiers/ [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Ackerman, S. (2011). Captain America, Meet Mother Russia: Soviets Had World War II ‘Super Soldiers’. [online] WIRED. Available at: https://www.wired.com/2011/07/soviet-super-soldiers/ [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Martin, S. (2017). United States of America armed services to pass £50M on digital BRAIN IMPLANTS to create SUPER SOLDIERS. [online] Express.co.uk. Available at: https://www.express.co.uk/news/science/827350/brain-implant-us-military-super-soldier [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Holmes, K. (2016). An Artificial Cyborg Implant Has Been Fitted on Humans for the First Time. [online] Creators. Available at: https://creators.vice.com/en_us/article/wnpvb5/cyborg-implant-north-sense-fitted-on-humans [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Heaven, D. (2013). First mind-reading implant gives rats telepathic power. [online] New Scientist. Available at: https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn23221-first-mind-reading-implant-gives-rats-telepathic-power/ [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Boot, M. (2013). Invisible Armies: An Epic History of Guerrilla Warfare from Ancient Times to the Present.
Sullivan, J. as well as Elkus, A. (2015). Urban Siege inwards Paris: H5N1 Spectrum of Armed Assault. [online] Smallwarsjournal.com. Available at: http://smallwarsjournal.com/jrnl/art/urban-siege-in-paris-a-spectrum-of-armed-assault [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Serle, J. (2016). Obama drone casualty numbers a fraction of those recorded yesteryear the Bureau. [online] The Bureau of Investigative Journalism. Available at: https://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/stories/2016-07-01/obama-drone-casualty-numbers-a-fraction-of-those-recorded-by-the-bureau [Accessed 31 May 2018].
Buat lebih berguna, kongsi:
