BY FATEMEH AMAN
The message from Washington these days appears to live that severing the link betwixt the Taliban in addition to Islamic Republic of Pakistan is the silverish bullet for peace inwards Afghanistan. It is, however, simplistic to portray the Taliban as the solely insurgent grouping inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan in addition to Islamic Republic of Pakistan as the solely relevant exterior actor. While the Taliban mightiness live the insurgent grouping alongside the most sympathizers in addition to members, at that spot are other groups active inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan that may non live influenced past times Pakistan. An enduring peace inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan is solely possible if it involves a bargain betwixt the Afghan regime in addition to the Taliban, in addition to addresses the challenge posed past times these other insurgent groups. US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo’s determination to appoint Zalmay Khalilzad as his Afghan envoy, tasked alongside mediating betwixt the Taliban in addition to Kabul, mightiness attention convey Afghan President Ashraf Ghani’s regime in addition to at to the lowest degree to a greater extent than or less factions of the Taliban together. Khalilzad has walked a fine describe betwixt Afghanistan’s many ethnic groups inwards the past. He helped effectively shape the country’s get-go post-Taliban regime in addition to organized the country’s get-go post-Taliban elections.
The electrical flow province of affairs inwards Afghanistan, however, is really dissimilar from that of the 2000s. Today, the Taliban receive got gained command of much of the country. Kabul remains out of insurgent hands, but it is nevertheless overwhelmed past times deepening rifts within the political establishment.
Both the Taliban in addition to the Afghan regime receive got spent to a greater extent than fourth dimension in addition to unloosen energy jockeying for seat inwards negotiations than inwards genuinely negotiating. Whenever either side has strengthened its position, it has rejected the sentiment of negotiations inwards favor of to a greater extent than fighting. But now, the Taliban in addition to Kabul aren’t but fighting i another. Both sides must consider the threat posed past times the Islamic State-Khurasan (IS-K).
For several years, experts receive got warned that ISIS tin sack recruit within Afghanistan. IS-K derives its advert from Khurasan Province, a historic advert for a portion that included most of modern Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan as good as much of Central Asia in addition to parts of modern Islamic Republic of Iran in addition to Pakistan. IS-K’s beingness came to lite inwards 2015 when the Islamic State named Hafiz Saeed Khan, a senior commander inwards the Tehrik-i-Taliban Islamic Republic of Pakistan (TTP) in addition to quondam Pakistani Taliban primary of the Orakzai District of Pakistan’s Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, as its head.
At first, the Taliban denied ISIS’s existence, calling it a “pretext” for the States in addition to the CIA to kicking the bucket on the trouble of Afghanistan. In 2016, Taliban spokesperson Zabiullah Mujahid rejected the sentiment that IS-K could live a threat to Afghanistan, proverb that “ISIS is neither welcomed inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan nor are ISIS’s ideas accepted past times our nation.” However, IS-K’s successes, in addition to its brutality, receive got since taken everyone, including the Taliban, past times surprise. Many, including the Taliban, receive got condemned the group’s actions.
The Taliban should non live considered a classic arrangement inwards price of its dependent plain in addition to structure. Today the Taliban is a multi-factional group, alongside to a greater extent than or less factions at odds fifty-fifty alongside each other. In a solid put down alongside an extremely rigid tribal structure, such as Afghanistan, it tin sack live hard to reconcile differences when at that spot is blood involved. But it is every bit possible to job tribal ties to attention accomplish a settlement.
The instance of Gulbuddin Hekmatyar is a classic example. Hekmatyar, a quondam warlord in addition to the terminal prime number government minister of Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan earlier the ascension of the Taliban, escaped to Islamic Republic of Iran after the Taliban took powerfulness inwards 1996. He thence announced his back upward for the Taliban but weeks earlier they were ousted from powerfulness inwards 2001 in addition to was expelled from Islamic Republic of Iran inwards 2002 for vowing to larn by the newly formed Afghan government. Hekmatyar later worked alongside the Taliban, thence separated from them, in addition to at i dot fifty-fifty called on his followers to back upward IS-K inwards its clashes alongside the Taliban. However, after changing his seat thence many times, he eventually reached a peace bargain alongside the regime inwards Kabul inwards 2017.
So far, maybe due to linguistic or cultural differences, IS-K’s operations inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan receive got been to a greater extent than muted than ISIS’s operations inwards Republic of Iraq in addition to Syria. IS-K leaders receive got non emphasized the restoration of the caliphate, for example, in addition to despite the group’s recent struggles inwards Republic of Iraq in addition to Syrian Arab Republic there’s been no apparent motion to shift its fundamental command to Afghanistan. IS-K’s aim seems to live initiating a religious war, indicated past times its targeted bombing of Shia gatherings in addition to mosques.
Unlike IS-K, the Taliban has to a greater extent than oftentimes than non not specifically targeted Shia in addition to other religious minority groups. However, that does non hateful its feelings toward those groups are positive. During the menstruation of Taliban dominion inwards the 1990s, Shia Hazaras experienced enormous brutality in addition to discrimination. There were extreme cases of violence, such as the 1998 massacre of thousands of Hazara men in addition to boys as revenge for the killing of thousands of Taliban fighters the previous yr inwards fighting over the metropolis of Mazar-e Sharif.
One of the biggest challenges inwards combating IS-K is that piffling is yet known close its operations, its strength, or its command structure. In job this is due to the propensity for other players inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan to deliberately either exaggerate or underestimate IS-K’s presence inwards social club to serve their ain political aims. Where it has been relatively slowly to seat the Taliban’s main unusual backers, IS-K’s back upward has been harder to track. The group’s motives are hard to ascertain since its members in addition to sympathizers seem to live attracted variously past times fiscal incentives, the group’s ideology, in addition to fifty-fifty feelings of revenge. IS-K’s operations are non necessarily assigned from a fundamental command but seem to live mostly spontaneous, which creates additional challenges as far as degrading its capabilities.
The brutality of IS-K’s operations, which has exceeded the Taliban’s, presents to a greater extent than or less other complication. The effectiveness in addition to deadliness of IS-K attacks receive got caused Afghan citizens to partially lose confidence inwards Kabul’s powerfulness to protect them. The danger is that if IS-K appears unbreakable using its cash distribution, that could interruption the morale of the Afghan safety forces in addition to practise an irreversible spiral of violence.
There is i positive human face to Afghanistan’s situation. Unlike inwards Republic of Iraq or Syria, at that spot receive got never been separatist tendencies inwards Afghanistan. For all of the country’s ethnic in addition to religious diversity, Afghans of all backgrounds innovate themselves as Afghan citizens in addition to never past times their ethnic or religious background. So far, the bulk of Afghans receive got rejected the brutality of IS-K. This fact, if combined alongside cutting off IS-K’s resources in addition to reaching to a greater extent than or less lasting agreements alongside the Talban, could live the terminal promise inwards bringing calm to Afghanistan.
Fatemeh Aman is a nonresident immature human inwards the Atlantic Council’s Southern Asia Center. Follow her on Twitter @FatemehAman.
Buat lebih berguna, kongsi:
