By Tamim Asey*
The Afghan authorities as well as its allies are winning battles inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan but non the war. The Afghan state of war started every bit the “good war” as well as every bit President Obama termed it later every bit “war of necessity” as well as was won inwards less than 2 months. Quickly the success of the Afghan state of war was termed every bit an international model for fighting global terrorism. It was hailed every bit a model of international cooperation but what has happened since then? Why is it is at nowadays at worst a “lost war” as well as at best a “forgotten war”. Is this state of war winnable? Who is the enemy nosotros are fighting? What are the costs of inaction as well as withdrawal as well as what are the costs of winning? What does victory hold off like? And finally how nosotros tin make victory? Do nosotros receive got the correct agency both on the Afghan side as well as on the side of the international community to win it as well as how long would it accept to win this war? I don’t receive got a crystal ball but firsthand experience as well as history tells me that the middle of the affair is that nosotros receive got been winning battles as well as losing the war; short-term tactical successes over long term strategic win over the enemy. The crust of the failures lies inwards a halfhearted approach to war, zigzag policy making as well as the lack of a broad-based reform minded authorities inwards Kabul. Essentially – the Afghan state of war nonetheless counts every bit the “good war” because it actually hasn’t met its objectives: destroying Al Qaeda, forbid Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan from becoming a prophylactic haven for international terrorist organizations as well as ensure no terrorist plot is planned from Afghan soil against US as well as its allies. On the opposite – Al Qaeda is non yet annihilated, in that place are to a greater extent than than xx terrorist organizations active inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan as well as ISKP has managed to create a foothold inwards Afghanistan. The inquiry is why such a reversal? The response is uncomplicated – a halfhearted as well as nether resourced get nether heavy scrutiny.
The state of war inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan is non a civil state of war no an insurgency every bit portrayed yesteryear roughly within the safety as well as armed forces circles. It started every bit a state of war against terrorism, which is at nowadays transformed to proxy state of war amongst elements of criminal economy, as well as terrorism. It is inwards this environs that terrorist organizations thrive hence making victory hard to claim inwards the absence of a long-term strategy as well as commitment.
At the outset -everyone had a excogitation to win the state of war but non a strategy to win the peace inwards Afghanistan. It is of import to banking corporation notation because if you lot hold off at the trajectory of state of war policy making you lot volition uncovering out that directly after the Taliban regime was overthrown nobody knew what to practise adjacent post service rootage Bonn conference inwards 2001. Former Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld, alongwith sometime President Bush did non desire a major US presence inwards Afghanistan. Then they had to develop Afghan forces to live able to keep safety as well as stability inwards the solid soil as well as got NATO involved as well as later nosotros receive got witnessed a plethora of haphazard often-contested prescriptions for the Afghan war. Nobody defined victory as well as what does victory hold off similar inwards a state of war every bit complicated as well as multifaceted similar Afghanistan. Since as well as so nosotros receive got seen a plethora of zig-zag policy making yesteryear the Americans as well as NATO allies oftentimes focused on curt term results as well as nether pressure level from their parliaments aimed at achieving quick wins. Afghan experts as well as policy makers at times joke that the alone solid soil which had a consistent as well as robust policy towards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan is Islamic Republic of Pakistan – move on the state of war going on plenty to wound but non at a boiling indicate to remember for an international retaliation. This policy has non changed as well as every bit nosotros tin come across is starting to pay dividend to GHQ inwards Rawalpindi.
On the otherhand – Taliban receive got transformed themselves from a regime hosting Al Qaeda who plotted the 9/11 tragic events to a terrorist grouping as well as later at nowadays a total blown “insurgent group” who supposedly poses no gamble to the due west as well as its allies as well as are but leading a national struggle as well as the Afghans postulate to reconcile amongst them.
The fact of the affair is that the Afghan state of war has been for many years inwards a stalemate but nonetheless winnable. The NATO develop as well as assistance missions has failed to interruption this stalemate for many reasons primary amid them a lack of resources, political considerations inwards US as well as European capitals as well as finally geopolitical priorities inwards other parts of the Blue Planet such every bit Syria, Republic of Iraq as well as nowadays Russia. But against all odds – the Afghan state of war is nonetheless winnable as well as a just state of war as well as one, which is vital for the national safety interests of the due west as well as Afghanistan. In fact – the state of war inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan symbolizes victory as well as defeat against terrorism. It all started hither as well as volition terminate here.
Afghanistan faces a proxy state of war imposed on its population from outside. Unlike Syrian Arab Republic Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan is non inwards a civil state of war or an insurgency every bit roughly may define this war. Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan faces a total blown proxy state of war imposed on its population thriving inwards an environs of criminal economic scheme as well as international terrorism. The inquiry remains how you lot win such a war?
What is the Afghan state of war as well as who are nosotros fighting?
The state of war inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan is multilayered as well as multifaceted amongst deep regional as well as global roots. It is non a civil state of war similar Syrian Arab Republic as well as nor it is an insurgency whereas a grouping of dissidents amongst no liberty command large swaths of solid soil as well as wage a state of war of national freedom. It is a proxy state of war coupled amongst elements of criminal economic scheme as well as terrorist groups operating inwards Afghanistan. For the Afghans it is a national struggle as well as state of war of liberty from the reign of terror financed as well as provided prophylactic havens exterior of Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan as well as for the international community it is the global state of war on terrorism. Afghan receive got suffered to a greater extent than than anyone as well as receive got been victims of this long war. According to the UN civilian casualties study – lastly twelvemonth to a greater extent than than 4000 civilians lost their lives inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan as well as over the lastly 17 years to a greater extent than than 80,000 Afghan civilians were killed. This is the cost Afghans are paying on a daily footing for this struggle.
Essentially – this state of war is every bit much virtually the portion as well as global safety every bit much every bit it is virtually the national safety interests of Afghanistan. More than xx terrorist scheme function nether diverse outfits inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan as well as create practise Afghan National Defense as well as Security Forces (ANDSF) whose primary objective is to excogitation as well as execute deadly terrorist attacks inwards the capitals of the portion as well as the west. The safety of Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan is tied to the safety of Tehran, Delhi, London, Berlin as well as New York.
Therefore – the state of war inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan is non alone the state of war of Afghans but likewise the state of war of the due west against its master copy motto of global terrorism. This consensus is unfortunately broken. When the global state of war on terrorism was launched it was due to broad-based consensus within Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan as well as the portion that the Taliban regime was toppled inwards a affair of days as well as it is just due to this the lack as well as breakdown of such a consensus that Taliban are at nowadays stronger as well as to a greater extent than terrorist groups are operating inwards Afghanistan. Taliban supply the umbrella for many of these regional as well as global terrorist groups to function inwards Afghanistan. The Taliban as well as these terrorist organizations savour a symbiotic human relationship as well as mutually feed on each other.
This is why it is crucial to debunk the myth that Taliban are no to a greater extent than a threat to the due west as well as the portion because they are waging an insurgency against the Afghan government. This volition alone live truthful if they receive got genuinely broken ranks amongst Al Qaeda as well as other groups. WE nonetheless receive got non seen bear witness of such a breakaway inwards ranks.
What is victory as well as how you lot win the war?
The ultimate terminate of the Afghan state of war comes amongst a political small town but through a decisive armed forces win on the battlefields. We should search for peace on the battlefields as well as non European capitals as well as the capitals of Afghan neighbors. Victory against Taliban as well as terrorist co-conspirators is a decisive armed forces win inwards the battlefield no affair at what cost followed yesteryear a political small town amongst the remnants of the Afghan Taliban. This is non the example now. The state of war is inwards a painful stalemate taking lives of dozens of Afghans on a daily footing as well as Taliban experience they receive got the upper manus inwards stance of the waning back upward for an unpopular state of war inwards the west. What the western politicians receive got failed to convey to their populations is that winning the state of war inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan against terrorism is direct related to the safety on the streets of Europe as well as the United States.
Meanwhile – i 3rd of the fighters inwards the Afghan battlefields are unusual fighters from Pakistan, Central Asia as well as Europe. They are transit fighters whose ultimate aim is to wound the portion as well as the west. For them the alone pick should live instruct out to your countries of origin, give upward or instruct killed.
This victory requires a long-term commitment; resources as well as a decisive armed forces win inwards the battlefields amongst a broad-based as well as credible Afghan partner.
What is needed for victory?
To make victory nosotros postulate a 3D approach. On the Defense side nosotros postulate to shell the Taliban armed forces mechanism yesteryear targeting their command as well as command structure, sources of financing as well as safehavens. We are at nowadays killing the expendable soldiers as well as at best mid marking commanders. The leadership of the Taliban as well as their unusual collaborators practise non pay whatever cost as well as are comfortably planning operations as well as killing Afghan as well as NATO service members inwards Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan from their prophylactic havens inwards Islamic Republic of Pakistan as well as increasingly at nowadays Islamic Republic of Iran as well as roughly Central Asian states.
On the diplomacy – the Afghan authorities as well as its NATO allies postulate to patch upward as well as convey dorsum the much needed but broken consensus of fighting terrorist every bit a collective safety threat. This consensus of safety for all every bit opposed to privatizing the state of war on terror needs to live restored.
And finally – Afghan as well as the Afghan authorities should start long term planning for an economical renaissance as well as increasingly taking responsibleness for its economical revival as well as funding of its safety forces. The short-term sources of finance are agriculture, transit as well as H2O piece long-term economical evolution of Transitional Islamic State of Afghanistan to convey much needed revenues tin rely on mining as well as natural resources development.
*Tamim Asey is the sometime Afghan Deputy Minister of Defense as well as Director General at the Afghan National Security Council. He is currently pursuing a Ph.D inwards Security studies inwards London. He tin live reached via twitter @tamimasey as well as Facebook @Tamim Asey.
Buat lebih berguna, kongsi:
