By Tim Robertson
On July 6, Tenzin Gyatso, the 14th Dalai Lama, celebrated his 83rd birthday inward Ladakh, the Himalayan part inward the Indian province of Jammu together with Kashmir. On the other side of the world’s highest mount gain sits Lhasa, the Tibetan majuscule that he fled inward 1959 during the Tibetan Uprising. The Dalai Lama has never been allowed to return. His has been a life lived inward exile. But fifty-fifty Lhasa, identify to the Jokhang Temple together with Potala Palace, was a the world away from the identify where Tenzin Gyato was born. Takster is a little hamlet inward the far northeast of the Tibetan plateau, inward the part of Amdo (these days, it’s purpose of the Chinese province of Qinghai). In his biography, Freedom inward Exile, the Dalai Lama writes of Takster: It was a little together with piteous settlement which stood on a colina overlooking a broad valley. Its pastures had non been settled or farmed for long, exclusively grazed past times nomads. The ground for this was the unpredictability of the atmospheric condition inward that area. During my early on childhood, my theatre unit of measurement was i of xx or so making a precarious living from the ground there.
When Thupten Gyatso, the 13th Dalai Lama, died inward 1933 a search political party was appointed to uncovering his reincarnation; they start reached Takster merely before Tenzin Gyatso’s 3rd birthday. Shortly thereafter, they sent give-and-take to the Regent inward Lhasa that they’d constitute the novel Dalai Lama; they together with so waited several months to have official confirmation.
At the time, command of mainland People's Republic of China was divided alongside one-time state of war machine cliques. Ma Bufang, the Hui Muslim warload who ruled over Qinghai, “began to brand trouble,” inward the words of the Dalai Lama; thus, the man child destined to go the religious together with political leader of Tibet was taken with his theatre unit of measurement to Kumbum monastery, “several hours away past times horse.” Two years of diplomatic toing together with froing followed together with eventually, with the payment of a ransom, Ma Bufang allowed the political party to go out Kumbum monastery together with go onwards to Lhasa.
Takster is a footnote inward the long history of Tibet; it would endure all but unremarkable if it were non the birthplace of the 14th Dalai Lama.
Today, it’s nonetheless a small, isolated village. For tourists visiting mainland People's Republic of China – taking inward the sights of Beijing, Shanghai, Xi’an, Chengdu, etc. – this side of the country’s extraordinary rising oft remains invisible: away from the large cities, at that spot is nonetheless widespread impoverishment. In places similar Takster it’s clear that China’s increment has disproportionately benefitted wealthy urbanities; today’s reality is the real contrary of the peasant-led revolution Mao Zedong hoped would remake China.
But Takster also tells some other storey of modern China, with its resurgent Han nationalism together with persecution of religious together with ethnic minorities.
It’s 7 kilometers from Takster to the side past times side closest village. The roads leading upwards the mount from Ping’an are all relatively novel upwards until the finally village, after which they’re pot-holed together with oft unsealed. The villages scattered upwards the mountain, where the bulk of people are Hui Muslims, are fairly typical of the region: there’s a little pump school, together with stores where shopkeepers stare at their phones patch waiting for customers. I spot a large regime edifice with the requisite Chinese Communist Party (CCP) insignia together with men function inward a little square, laying pavers together with planting trees.
Takster is somehow different, though. At start sight, it looks similar the other villages. Vegetation is sparse, at that spot are old cars together with decrepit motorcycles parked haphazardly, together with all the homes are small, one-story dwellings with large courtyards. But all the gates are closed together with locked, which is odd inward a hamlet where everyone knows i some other together with many people are related. It’s unopen to 10:30 a.m. when nosotros arrive, but at that spot is no i around. Even the police pull are nowhere to endure seen. We common inward front end of a requisitioned schoolhouse desk with ii police pull shields leaning against it, but the comically little chairs are empty.
The Dalai Lama’s one-time identify isn’t precisely inconspicuous; the CCP withdraw hold “renovated” it together with yous tin give notice reckon the gilded roof every bit yous drive toward Takster. But that’s the best sentiment nosotros get; the theatre is behind a four-meter high greyness brick wall and, on the 24-hour interval we’re there, the wooden gate, draped inward Tibetan khatags, is locked.
In lieu of people, the theatre is watched over past times a solitary safety camera, aimed at the entrance. One hundred meters downward the route a domestic dog emerges from a house, together with so the audio of somebody hammering metallic begins to band out over the village. As nosotros brand our agency toward the exclusively sign of life we’ve seen or heard since arriving, a Chinese-speaking Tibetan homo emerges from a identify attached the one-time identify of the Dalai Lama. Looking at me, he asks: “Where are yous from?” But before I tin give notice reply he turns to my driver and, to a greater extent than alarmed, asks, “Are yous Tibetan?” When the driver answers inward the affirmative, the villager – with an obvious sense of urgency – tells us to go out chop-chop because the identify is heavily surveilled. His vocalization is foreboding together with his jerky, hurried gestures brand it clear that this isn’t a identify to loiter.
My instantly visibly anxious driver together with I hurry dorsum to the car, hoping that the makeshift police pull checkpoint is nonetheless unoccupied. Although few words are spoken inward our brief run across with the local villager, much is conveyed: Tibetans empathise the reach, power, together with unjustness of the CCP. They’ve spent their whole lives beingness persecuted because they’re Tibetans.
Beijing evidently doesn’t desire Takster becoming a pilgrimage site for Tibetans; the Dalai Lama represents a challenge non to Chinese mightiness per se, but to its national(ist) narrative. Martin Jacques, author together with scholar of modern China, has argued that mainland People's Republic of China is different from other patch states together with is amend understood every bit a “civilization-state.” The CCP’s claims to legitimacy are closely linked to its mightiness to foster an icon of itself every bit the guardian of China’s 6,000 twelvemonth old civilization. The claim, therefore, that Tibet is culturally, linguistically, together with geographically distinct from mainland People's Republic of China together with its civilization undermines the CCP’s claims to legitimacy.
Yet, if, every bit Beijing claims, Tibet is an intrinsic purpose of mainland People's Republic of China together with if the emerging superpower is, every bit it claims, a benign strength (unlike Western majestic powers), together with so it doesn’t brand sense to ban people from visiting sites similar Takster. If Takster is purpose of mainland People's Republic of China inward the same agency that, say, Shanghai is, together with so all Chinese people (including Tibetans) should endure complimentary to go there. But, of course, Takster is non the same every bit Shanghai, nor are Tibetans, inward the eyes of the CCP, the same every bit Han Chinese. There is a tension, inward other words, betwixt the myth-making that passes for official Chinese history, the national narrative that’s the ground for so much province propaganda, together with the lived reality for China’s minorities.
China today is unrecognizable every bit the socialist utopia envisioned past times Mao. Since his decease inward 1976, the CCP has shown itself to endure flexible on matters that were i time ideological imperatives. Thus, the i time nominally atheist province has, inward recent years, seen a resurgence inward religiosity alongside its citizens. The CCP has allowed this – fifty-fifty encouraged it inward some instances – to the extent that it remains apolitical. But if religious belief is accompanied past times or becomes the ground for calls for independence or autonomy or greater freedom, together with so it’s ruthlessly repressed.
With each passing year, every bit the Dalai Lama grows older, at that spot are whispers nearly what volition hand off when he dies: it’s unthinkable that Beijing would let a Tibetan search political party to acquit out the chore of finding his reincarnation unimpeded. The Dalai Lama has made some vague comments that he may endure the finally reincarnation or that his reincarnation may endure constitute exterior Tibet in, say, Bharat or Nepal. But until he passes together with Beijing reveals its hand, this all remains hypothetical.
When nosotros are a few kilometers out of Takster, my driver relaxes a bit, puts on some Tibetan rap music together with nosotros resume the conversation we’d been having earlier. “What exercise yous intend volition happen,” I ask, “when the Dalai Lama dies?”
“Maybe I volition withdraw hold a chip to a greater extent than freedom,” he replies unconvincingly. He qualifies it with, “But I don’t actually know, though.” He thinks it’s inevitable that the CCP volition travail to install their ain pliant “Dalai Lama” (like it did when the Panchen Lama, the mo highest ranking lama inward the Gelug tradition of Tibetan Buddhism, died inward 1989); a figurehead the CCP tin give notice indicate to every bit show of its credence together with honor for minorities, but somebody who’s merely an extension of its authority.
A few weeks afterwards I am inward Dharamshala, Bharat with a Tibetan friend who’s spent most of his life inward exile. When I tell him nearly my see to the Dalai Lama’s birthplace together with relate the conversation I had with my driver, he is dismissive of that prediction. It is impossible, he says, that Tibetans living inward Chinese-occupied Tibet would stand upwards for such an affront to their faith. If the CCP interferes with the search for the Dalai Lama’s reincarnation, he warns, it could endure the burn downward that sparks a revolution.
These ii responses are non necessarily reflective of the views of the bulk living inward occupied-Tibet together with those inward exile, but they are emblematic of the gulf betwixt the lived experiences of the ii communities. Both endure because of China’s occupation, but they endure inward real different ways together with this shapes their hopes, aspirations together with expectations.
All Tibetans portion a civilisation together with history, but China, inward add-on to occupying Tibetan land, has driven a wedge betwixt its people. Many of those living inward Chinese-administered territory can’t leave, patch many of those living inward exile withdraw hold never fix human foot inward Tibet.
The on-going Chinese-Tibetan conflict is non to a greater extent than oft than non treated every bit an urgent thing past times the international community. Beijing restricts access to Tibet, so the menses of data is tightly controlled, together with mainland People's Republic of China is an increasingly powerful strength inward the world. But the longer mainland People's Republic of China is allowed to stay unaccountable for its business of Tibet together with the oppression of its people, the harder it volition endure to twosome the split betwixt a people whose lived sense of isolation, occupation, together with exclusion withdraw hold been so different.
Tim Robertson is an independent journalist together with writer. He tweets @timrobertson12.
Buat lebih berguna, kongsi:
