Russia's S-300 Or S-400: F-35 Killer Or Overhyped?

Dave Majumdar

The Pentagon is casting dubiety on the effectiveness of Russian-made air defense forcefulness systems. The Pentagon’s movement appears to endure aimed at deterring Turkey from purchasing the Russian-made S-400. However, the Pentagon’s statements telephone cry upward into inquiry why the U.S.A. as well as its allies are investing hundreds of billions of dollars into stealth aircraft as well as stealthy long-range cruise missiles if Russian-made surface-to-air weapons are completely ineffective. Until the Pentagon’s Apr nineteen press briefing, the Defense Department would routinely scaremonger how the S-400 would effectively plow an expanse into an anti-access/area denial (A2/AD) bubble.


The Pentagon noted that all allied missiles hitting their targets within Syrian Arab Republic during the Apr xiii raid—despite the Russians’ plainly ridiculous assertions that the Syrians shot downward the bulk of the incoming missiles. “Following our operations, Russian Federation falsely claimed Syrian Arab Republic air defenses shot downward a pregnant number of missiles, when inwards fact nosotros hitting all of our targets,” Pentagon Chief spokesperson Dana W. White told reporters on Apr 19. “Of the surface-to-air missiles that the Assad government launched, nearly every 1 was launched after the end of our missiles hitting their targets.”
White, however, went on to say that Russian manufactured air defenses were completely ineffective. “The Russian manufactured air defense forcefulness systems were totally ineffective,” White said. “Russia as well as the government demonstrated the ineffectiveness of their systems 1 time to a greater extent than 2 days subsequently when those systems engaged accidentally.”

Joint Staff Director Lt. Gen. Kenneth F. McKenzie Jr. walked those comments dorsum somewhat. McKenzie noted that Russian air defenses were active during the American-led assail on Syria, but did non stimulate to engage the incoming attack. “In the assail on Fri night, Russian air defenses were energized,” McKenzie said. “They were scanning, they had a [Beriev A-50] Mainstay air defense forcefulness aircraft up. They did non involve to engage, thus I can't speculate most why they did or didn't create that.”

However, McKenzie stood past times the comment that Russian-made air defenses were ineffective—but allowed that at that spot is a deviation betwixt the antiquated systems operated past times the Syrians as well as those used past times the Kremlin’s ain forces. “I tin forcefulness out enjoin you lot though that the residue of Syrian air defense forcefulness capability, which is completely Russian made, Russian designed, Russian supported, engaged extensively as well as comprehensively failed,” McKenzie said. “So I intend there's a distinction there, as well as I recognize that. The Russians didn't create anything, although they're real closely allied to all the systems that the Syrians deployed to no effect.”

McKenzie as well as White’s comments seem to endure implicitly aimed at Turkey, a wayward NATO ally that the U.S.A. is trying to convince to forego purchasing the Russian S-400 Triumph system. “We receive got talked to the Turks most the number of interoperability,” White said. “But ultimately the Turks receive got to create upward one's head what's inwards their best strategic interest, as well as that's for Ankara to determine.”

If nosotros receive got the Pentagon’s assertion that Russian air defenses are completely ineffective, as well as then why is the U.S.A. investing hundreds of billions of dollars into stealth technology? The declaration used to justify the outrageous toll of stealth aircraft only evaporates since the threat they were built to counter does non exist.

Thus far, the Northrop Grumman B-2 Spirit has toll to a greater extent than than $45 billion as well as the Lockheed Martin F-22 Raptor has toll almost $67 billion to educate as well as field. Meanwhile, Lockheed Martin’s F-35 Joint Strike Fighter plan is fix to toll $406 billion as well as the Northrop Grumman B-21 is fix to toll at to the lowest degree $56 billion—but the Air Force refuses to liberate toll figures for the Raider. And none of these numbers includes sustainment costs for these aircraft.

In add-on to the aircraft, the Pentagon continues to invest inwards stealthy cruise missiles such equally the JASSM-ER, the hereafter Long Range Standoff (LRSO) weapon as well as a host of other long-range missiles to overcome enemy—overwhelmingly Russian-built—air defenses. What is the indicate if Russian-built air defenses—which are used past times the overwhelming bulk of threats—are useless? Even the Chinese largely purpose copies of Moscow’s hardware.

For the adjacent House or Senate Armed Services Committee hearing, hold off leaders from the Pentagon to audio the alert over the threat posed past times the S-300, S-400 as well as other Russian-made air defenses to justify their programs as well as budgets. There volition undoubtedly endure much manus wringing most A2/AD bubbles inwards Kaliningrad or Crimea or elsewhere. The cycle volition laid about anew.
Buat lebih berguna, kongsi:

Trending Kini: