Leonid Bershidsky
Sir Timothy Berners-Lee, credited alongside inventing the World Wide Web, tweeted upwards a tempest on Thursday, reassuring network users that they could reassert command over their data—and the web’s future— later the Cambridge Analytica-Facebook scandals. He’s right, but non necessarily inwards the means he imagines. “What tin forcefulness out spider web users do?” Berners-Lee wrote. “Get involved. Care close your data. It belongs to you. If nosotros each lead keep a niggling of the fourth dimension nosotros pass using the spider web to struggle for the web, I retrieve we’ll last ok. Tell companies in addition to your authorities representatives that your information in addition to the spider web matter.” I empathize his agony close what has happened to his invention, in addition to I envy his optimism close the efficiency of activism in addition to regulation. Both are, of course, useful inwards rolling dorsum the massive invasion of privacy nosotros lead keep all suffered, non quite knowingly, inwards recent years. But fifty-fifty if nosotros acquire “woke” to the invasion, there’s non much nosotros tin forcefulness out exercise close it.
Sure, ane tin forcefulness out piece of occupation inwards Facebook settings, unopen off every possible form of data-based mention targeting in addition to kill, ane past times one, all the “interests” Facebook has ascribed to y'all on the terra firma of your online in addition to offline demeanour (if y'all don’t know how it’s done, don’t worry, most people are similar you; click “Settings,” hence “Ads”). One tin forcefulness out exercise the same on Twitter (it’s nether “Your Twitter data”). One tin forcefulness out delete all one’s previous activity from a Google account. But ane can’t hence easily disable the constant information sharing that occurs on every website that uses programmatic advertising. These sites acquire all sorts of information close a visitor—above all, the browsing in addition to search history—and acquire inwards available to advertisers (or, rather, to algorithms that “represent” them) hence that they tin forcefulness out bid for your eyeballs. Nor is at that topographic point whatsoever tardily means to purge the detailed dossiers collected close each of us past times information brokers, companies that collect information for resale; Cambridge Analytica, too, essentially served every bit a information broker, acquiring information from a Cambridge professor to parcel in addition to resell it to election campaigns. Most apps that nosotros role on mobile phones collect in addition to portion our data, too.
Is it genuinely possible to reassert control? That’s easier said than done. Our information are no longer ours, in addition to it’s used inwards ways we’d reject—if nosotros had the gamble to weigh inwards on the matter.
Berners-Lee’s innovation has been subverted past times a belief that Facebook master copy executive officeholder Mark Zuckerberg exhibited inwards a recent New York Timesinterview. He said this: Our mission is to construct a community for everyone inwards the terra firma in addition to to convey the terra firma closer together. And a genuinely of import constituent of that is making a service that people tin forcefulness out afford. H5N1 lot of the people, in ane lawsuit y'all acquire past times the outset billion people, can’t afford to pay a lot. Therefore, having it last gratis in addition to lead keep a trouble organisation model that is ad-supported ends upwards beingness genuinely of import in addition to aligned.
Since the web’s early on days, it’s been total of freebies, in addition to entrepreneurs lead keep learned to offering them inwards a touchstone way. They misrepresent information collection to users every bit something that shouldn’t bother a sane mortal in addition to sold advertisers on the thought that the information collection could interpret into to a greater extent than precise mention targeting than that of traditional media. That’s non merely the Facebook model—it’s that of Google, Twitter in addition to fifty-fifty traditional publishers who lead keep introduced programmatic advertising to their websites in addition to apps. What nosotros users postulate to empathize is that this is non the solely model.
Right now, the terra firma is watching the biggest initial money offering inwards history — that of the messenger Telegram. It has already attracted $850 meg in addition to is inwards the procedure of doubling the amount. The thought behind it is to exercise a blockchain-based economic scheme within Telegram’s 170 million-strong user community, using a cryptocurrency to transfer value in addition to purchase stuff. This planned ecosystem—which, ane must admit, hasn’t been built yet—will lead keep room for advertising, too, but it volition last to a greater extent than akin to traditional media advertising than to the microtargeting offered past times the Googles in addition to Facebooks. Telegram has world channels, whose owners tin forcefulness out sell ads inwards them to advertisers interested inwards their audience. Neither Telegram nor the channel owners postulate to collect whatsoever personal information inwards guild to monetize the community. Telegram tin forcefulness out alive off a per centum of transactions inwards its ecosystem. The “media” based on the platform merely needs to attract large audiences for narrowly targeted content. Telegram says it doesn’t portion users’ information alongside anyone at all.
My promise is that newer, privacy-respecting trouble organisation models, similar the ane envisioned past times Telegram, volition naturally supervene upon the onetime model, at to the lowest degree inwards the social media arena. Messengers lead keep a natural synergy alongside fintech in addition to niche media, in addition to pretty much whatsoever of it tin forcefulness out last monetized without selling information to the highest bidder.
It’s harder, however, to imagine this happening to search or to the strongest traditional publishers, capable of collecting both subscription in addition to advertising revenue. That’s where the Berners-Lee method—pressure in addition to regulation—is belike the best. It would last fair to allow those users who don’t desire to hand upwards information or meet ads, targeted or otherwise, to pay a subscription fee—the means they exercise on Spotify, for example—and to lead keep others genuinely sell their information past times giving them a per centum of the mention revenue they generate. If platforms pass upwards to offering these opportunities, regulators tin forcefulness out forcefulness them.
We don’t lead keep to last suckers or chattel inwards the network economy. Berners-Lee’s message close clawing dorsum our ability is an of import telephone band to activeness inwards a terra firma where truthful privacy is no longer possible. Bloomberg View
Buat lebih berguna, kongsi:
